The Role of Antiviral Therapy in the Natural
History
of Hepatitis C Fibrosis
Joanne C. Imperial, MD
Associate Professor of Medicine
Stanford University School of Medicine
The development of liver fibrosis is a
critical event in the natural history of chronic hepatitis C virus
infection. Fibrosis is the predominant cause of morbidity and mortality
from this disease and is responsible for the development of liver
decompensation, hepatocellular carcinoma and death in a percentage of
chronically-infected individuals.
Liver biopsy is considered mandatory
for accurate staging of early fibrosis. A recent prospective study was done
to assess the accuracy of a combination of serum biochemical markers for
diagnosing fibrosis, including early stages. Eleven serum markers were
assessed, as well as the METAVIR fibrosis stage. A fibrosis score combining
the most informative markers and taking into account age and gender was
constructed. High negative-predictive values were obtained for scores
ranging from 0 to .10 and high positive-predictive values were obtained for
scores ranging from .6 to 1.0. Using a combination of simple serum markers
to predict fibrosis could potentially lead to a 50% reduction in the number
of liver biopsies performed in patients with chronic HCV. A serum
hyaluronic acid level of <110 mcg/l was associated with a 97% negative
predictive value for significant fibrosis.
The effect on hepatic fibrosis using
pegylated interferons has recently been studied by several investigators.
Heathcote randomized 271 patients with bridging fibrosis or cirrhosis to
receive either interferon alfa-2a 3MU TIW, peginterferon alfa-2a 90 mcg QW
or peginterferon alfa-2a 180 mcg QW. SVR was reported in 8%, 15% and 30% of
these treatment groups. In a subset of patients who underwent paired liver
biopsies, histologic response (greater than a 2-point decrease in a total
Histologic Activity Index score) at week 72 was 31%, 44% and 51%
respectively. Even among those individuals that did not have a sustained
response to treatment, histologic improvement was observed in approximately
33% of patients. Poynard pooled individual data from 3010 treatment-naïve
patients with pre and post treatment liver biopsies from four randomized
treatment trials. Ten different regimens combining standard interferon,
pegylated interferon, and ribavirin were compared. Improvement in
inflammation and necrosis varied from 39% in patients treated with standard
interferon monotherapy for 24 weeks to 73% in those treated optimally with
peginterferon and ribavirin. All regimens reduced the annual rate of
fibrosis progression compared with pretreatment rates. Fibrosis stage,
sustained viral response, age less than 40 years, body mass index of <27
kg/m, minimal pretreatment inflammation, and viral load less than 3.5
million copies/mL were independent factors associated with the absence of
significant fibrosis after treatment in this analysis.
Although the goal of antiviral therapy
is to achieve sustained viral eradication, recent studies have suggested
that secondary goals of preventing progression of fibrosis or liver cancer
can be accomplished, even in treatment nonresponders. Several retrospective
studies to date and one recent prospective study have documented prevention
of HCC after 24 or 48 weeks of therapy with interferon monotherapy in
patients who do not have a sustained viral response. There is only one
published, controlled trial to date using interferon maintenance therapy and
the results demonstrated that continuing interferon for two years in a
subpopulation of nonresponders stabilized fibrosis and reduced inflammation
on serial liver biopsies.
Risk factors for progressive fibrosis
include age >40 years at acquisition of HCV infection, presence of bridging
fibrosis on initial liver biopsy, increased body weight with hepatic
steatosis, excess alcohol consumption >25 g/d, excess hepatic iron, and
immunosuppression. There are no prospective studies that have looked at
concomitant therapy using antifibrotic agents or cytoprotective drugs in
prevention of hepatitis C fibrosis progression. Colchicine and
ursodeoxycholic therapy have no direct antiviral effect, but no data is
available regarding the role of these drugs as long-term therapy in patients
with HCV cirrhosis. Vitamin E has some benefit in reducing ALT levels in
patients with HCV infection, but has not been studied prospectively as an
antifibrotic agent.
Ongoing studies are planned
specifically to examine the role of antiviral therapy on progression of
fibrosis and clinical hepatitis C-related liver disease. There are two
studies that have been launched to evaluate maintenance therapy using
pegylated interferons: the HALT-C trial, sponsored by the NIH, and the
COPILOT (Colchicine vs PegIntron Long-Term), sponsored by Schering Hepatitis
Innovations. Both studies are planning to evaluate the effect of four years
of treatment on the progression of fibrosis and development of liver failure
and/or hepatocellular carcinoma. Together, these studies should resolve the
very important question regarding the role of antiviral therapy in the
natural history of hepatitis C fibrosis.
References
1. Friedman SL. Evaluation of fibrosis and hepatitis
C. Am J Med 107:27S-30S, 1999.
2. Heathcote EJ, Shiffman ML,
Cooksley, et al. Peginterferon alfa-2a in patients with chronic hepatitis C
and cirrhosis. N Engl J Med 343:1673-1680, 2001.
3. Poynard T, McHutchison J, Davis
GL, et al. Impact of interferon alfa-2b and ribavirin on prgression of liver
fibrosis in patients with chronic hepatitis C. Hepatology 32:1131-1137,
2000.
4. Poynard T, Ratziu V, Benhamou Y,
Di Martino VD, Bedossa P, Opolon P. Fibrosis in patients with chronic
hepatitis C: detection and signficance. Semin Liver Dis 20:47-55, 2000.
5. Shiffman ML, Hofmann CM, Contos
MJ, et al. A randomized, controlled trial of maintenance interferon therapy
for patients with chronic hepatitis C virus and persistent viremia.
Gastroenterology 117: 1165-1172, 1999.
PEG interferon and ribavirin
reduce liver fibrosis rate in hepatitis C
A combination of pegylated interferon and ribavirin
significantly reduces
the rate of fibrosis progression in patients with hepatitis C, according to
research published in the May issue of Gastroenterology.
A group of international researchers evaluated the effect
of pegylated
(PEG) interferon alfa-2b and ribavirin on liver fibrosis in patients with
chronic hepatitis C.
Individual data from 3010 naive patients, with
pretreatment and
post-treatment biopsies from 4 randomized trials, were pooled.
Ten different regimens combining standard interferon, PEG
interferon, and
ribavirin were compared.
The impact of each regimen was estimated by the percentage
of patients with
at least one grade improvement in the necrosis and inflammation (METAVIR
score).
It was also assessed by the percentage of patients with at
least one stage
worsening in fibrosis METAVIR score, and by the fibrosis progression rate
per year.
Necrosis and inflammation improvement ranged from 39%
(interferon, 24
weeks) to 73% (optimized PEG interferon and ribavirin).
Fibrosis worsening ranged from 23% (interferon, 24 weeks)
to 8% (optimized
PEG interferon and ribavirin).
The team found that all regimens significantly reduced the
fibrosis
progression rates in comparison to rates before treatment.
Furthermore, the reversal of cirrhosis was observed in 49%
of 153 patients
with baseline cirrhosis.
Necrosis and inflammation improved by 73% with PEG
interferon and ribavirin.
Gastroenterology
Six factors were found to be independently associated with
the absence of
significant fibrosis after treatment.
These included baseline fibrosis stage (odds ratio [OR] =
0.12), sustained
viral response (OR = 0.36), and age less than 40 years (OR = 0.51).
The other associated factors were body mass index less
than 27 kg/m2 (OR =
0.65), no or minimal baseline activity (OR = 0.70), and viral load less
than 3.5 millions copies per milliliter (OR = 0.79).
Professor Thierry Poynard, of the University of Paris VI,
Paris, France,
concluded on behalf of the group, "PEG-interferon and ribavirin combination
significantly reduces the rate of fibrosis progression in patients with
hepatitis C."
In an accompanying Editorial, Professor Michael J.P.
Arthur, of Southampton
General Hospital, England, comments, "The study of Poynard et al.
challenges all of us to accept that the traditional view of cirrhosis as a
progressive, irreversible disease is no longer correct.
"This augurs well for the future of our patients with
chronic HCV
infection, particularly if they clear the virus with treatment," he adds.
"The study also encourages further scientific
investigation of the key cell
and molecular mechanisms of liver fibrosis.
"It raises the prospect that an antifibrotic agent, aimed
at promoting
regression of disease, may be an important therapeutic strategy for the
future," he concludes.
Gastroenterology 2002; 122(5): 1303-13
03 May 2002