Treatment for Chronic Hepatitis C:
Updated Swedish Consensus Guidelines
In
1999 a Swedish national expert panel published recommendations for the
treatment of chronic hepatitis C (HCV) infection. Recently, pegylated
interferon (peg-IFN) products have been introduced, and an increased
knowledge concerning treatment of acute HCV and HCV-human immunodeficiency
virus (HIV) coinfection has been gained.
As a result of this, an
update of the Swedish recommendations was developed following an expert
meeting in October 2002. The panel now recommends the use of peg-IFN
together with ribavirin as the standard treatment.
Following are the primary
recommendations for various patient groups:
-
Owing to the excellent
response rates in HCV genotype 2 and 3 infections, these patients can be
treated for 24 weeks without preceding liver biopsy;
- For patients with
genotype 1 infection (with a slightly below 50% sustained response rate
after 48 weeks treatment) and only mild histological disease, treatment
can be postponed until future better treatment options become available;
-
In patients who fail to
achieve a 99% reduction (2 log drop) in viral titre after 12 weeks of
treatment, discontinuation of therapy is recommended;
-
Patients previously
treated with IFN monotherapy and not having achieved a sustained
virological response are recommended the same combination treatment as
treatment-naive patients;
-
IFN monotherapy is
recommended in patients with acute hepatitis C;
-
For children with
chronic HCV infection, combination treatment is mainly recommended in
clinical trials;
-
For HCV-HIV coinfected
patients, combination treatment is recommended and preferably given when
blood CD4 counts are above 350/ml and before antiretroviral treatment
(ART) is needed;
-
Concurrent ART or prominent liver fibrosis requires frequent monitoring
because of the increased risk for mitochondrial toxicity and liver
failure.
Department of Infectious
Diseases, Sahlgrenska University Hospital/Ostra, Goteborg, Sweden.
01/12/04
Reference
R Wejstal and others. Chronic hepatitis C: updated Swedish consensus.
Scandanavian Journal of
Infectious Diseases
35(8): 445-51. December
2003.
HCV Patients with Genotype 1b May Show a Sustained
Response and ALT Improvement After Prolonged Re-treatment with Interferon
Alfa
The aim of the current
pilot study was to investigate the efficacy of prolonged interferon alfa (IFN)
retreatment for 3 years in chronic hepatitis C patients with high viral load
and IFN treatment-resistant genotype 1b.
The study was conducted in
12 patients, not HCV RNA-negative after completion of initial treatment.
Retreatment consisted of administration of 6 million international units (MIU)
of natural interferon-alfa two or three times a week for 3 years.
Results
One patient withdrew for
personal reasons. All other 11 patients completed treatment without any
serious adverse reactions and were followed for 3 years.
Of the patients, 4 (36%)
showed a sustained virological response, 5 (45%) showed a biochemical
response, and 2 (18%) relapsed after retreatment. All patients with a
sustained response had a transient response to initial therapy. Patients
showing a sustained response tested negative for HCV RNA within the first 6
months of retreatment.
The authors conclude,
“After prolonged IFN retreatment, a significant number of patients showed a
sustained response for the first time and long-term improvement in ALT
level.”
Department of Internal
Medicine, Shin-Kokura Hospital, Kitakyushu, Japan
02/06/04
Reference
H Nomura and
others. Pilot study of prolonged interferon-alpha retreatment in chronic
hepatitis C patients with genotype 1b.
Hepatology Research
27(4): 266-271. December 2003.
Efficacy of Early Retreatment with Interferon Beta for
Relapse in Patients with Chronic Hepatitis C Genotype Ib
Interferon (IFN)
retreatment for hepatitis C virus (HCV) relapsers has been effective under
some conditions. Japanese researchers conducted a randomized, controlled
trial of IFN beta retreatment for HCV relapsers after failure of IFN alfa.
The investigators gave IFN
beta 6MIU therapy to 43 patients who had relapse of HCV after 24 weeks of
IFN alfa monotherapy.
The 43 patients were
randomly assigned to two groups: Group A started retreatment within 4 weeks
after relapse; and Group B started retreatment 24 weeks or more after
relapse.
Results
Nine patients showed
sustained virological response (SR) to the retreatment. All of these
patients were in a low viral load subgroup. The SR rate in Group A (8/22,
36%) was significantly higher than in Group B (1/21, 5%) (P=0.0128).
Among patients with lower
viral load, the SR rate in Group A (8/10, 80%) was also significantly higher
than in Group B (1/8, 13%) (P=0.0076).
The authors conclude, “The
retreatment with IFN beta is effective for patients with HCV low viral load,
and the sooner after the relapse the retreatment is started, the better the
clinical results will be.”
Department of Internal
Medicine, Shin-Kokura Hospital, 1-3-1 Kanada, Kokurakitaku, 803-8505,
Kita-Kyushu, Japan.
02/04/04
Reference
H Nomura and
others. Efficacy of early retreatment with interferon beta for relapse in
patients with genotype Ib chronic hepatitis C. Hepatology Research
28(1): 36-40. January 2004.
Is a 48-week Course of Treatment with Peginterferon Plus
Ribavirin Too Short to Maximize a Sustained Viral Response Among Patients
with Hepatitis C virus Genotype 1?
Hepatitis C virus (HCV) is
a major cause of mortality and morbidity and has infected 2.7 million
individuals in the United States alone. Although there have been major
advances in therapy for infection with HCV, patients infected with genotype
1 strains have a much poorer prognosis for clearing the virus than do
patients infected with genotype non-1 strains, even if they receive
treatment with high-dose
pegylated interferon (IFN) plus ribavirin.
Therapy with pegylated IFN
plus ribavirin is associated with a response rate of ~ 50% among patients
infected with HCV genotype 1; also, the regimen is expensive and is
associated with a number of predictable toxicities. Flu-like syndrome,
depression, and alterations in hemoglobin levels and white blood cell (WBC)
counts are common adverse events that occur with prolonged therapy with this
regimen.
Consequently, it is not
trivial to suggest the use of longer durations of therapy with this regimen,
because of both the cost of therapy and the attendant toxicities. The
response rate among patients infected with HCV of genotype non-1 is ~ 80%.
It is important to attempt to improve the response rates among patients
infected with genotype 1, so as to obtain approximately the same response
rate as that observed among patients not infected with genotype 1, given the
severe long-term sequelae attendant to continued rounds of replication of
HCV.
In the current study,
researchers present an analysis of a large trial of pegylated IFN plus
ribavirin. The results of this trial have been presented elsewhere [Manns
and others. Peginterferon alfa-2b plus ribavirin compared with interferon
alfa-2b plus ribavirin for initial treatment of chronic hepatitis C: a
randomized trial. Lancet 2001; 358: 958-965].
The objective of the study
was to develop models and to examine the effect of duration of therapeutic
response on outcome. The central idea of these analyses is that the major
benefit of antiviral therapy can be seen through its effect on the virus
load.
The investigators wanted
to determine whether the current state-of-the-art 48-week duration of
pegylated IFN plus ribavirin therapy is optimal for patients infected with
HCV of genotype 1.
It was thought that there
may be an association between the duration of therapeutic response during
drug therapy (i.e., having an undetectable HCV load in serum for a specific
number of weeks continuously) and the probability of attaining a long-term
response after discontinuation of therapy.
A model predicting SVR was
generated; it included the following covariates: duration of continuous non-detectability
of an HCV load in serum, estimated creatinine clearance, and whether the
isolate was of genotype 1.
The validation model
demonstrated positive and negative predictive values as well as sensitivity
and specificity exceeding 90%.
The model predicted that
patients infected with HCV genotype 1 require continuous non-detectability
of virus load in serum for 36 and 32 weeks, to attain 90% and 80%
probabilities, respectively, of a SVR.
The average time to clear
serum of genotype-1 virus was 30.4 weeks, which indicates that the 48-week
duration of therapy provided a suboptimal probability of a SVR.
Conclusions
For some patients,
suboptimal therapy with pegylated IFN plus ribavirin may need to be of
longer duration than the currently recommended 48 weeks. If the hypothesis
can be proved to be true, it has the possibility of adding
14%
more patients to the long-term response group.
This hypothesis requires
prospective validation.
Ordway Research Institute,
Albany, New York.
03/17/04
Reference
G L Drusano and S L Preston. A
48-Week Duration of Therapy with Pegylated Interferon 2b
plus Ribavirin May Be Too Short to Maximize Long-Term Response among
Patients Infected with Genotype-1 Hepatitis C Virus.
The Journal of Infectious
Diseases 189(6):
964-970. March 15, 2004.
www.hivandhepatitis.com
Pegasys plus Copegus: Newly Published Data Reports Highest
Overall Sustained Virological Response Ever - 63%
Alan Franciscus, Editor-in-Chief
The Annals of Internal Medicine recently
published an article on the clinical trial data results from a large
international multcenter phase III clinical trial in order to assess the
safety and efficacy of 24 or 48 weeks of treatment with Pegasys plus Copegus
at low or standard ribavirin dose.
The study was a randomized, double-blind trial that enrolled 1,311 hepatitis
C positive patients from 99 international centers. The lead author of the
study was S.J. Hadziyannis, MD, for the Pegasys International Study Group.
All patients were treated with Pegasys 180 µg /week and were randomized into
four treatment arms:
• 24 weeks - Pegasys plus ribavirin 800 mg/daily.
• 24 weeks - Pegasys plus ribavirin 1000 or 1200 mg/daily.
• 48 weeks - Pegasys plus ribavirin 800 mg/daily.
• 48 weeks - Pegasys plus ribavirin 1000 or 1200 mg/daily.
The primary endpoint of this study was end of treatment
response and sustained virological response at the end of treatment and
during the 12 to 24 weeks of follow-up.
It is well known that certain co-factors can influence treatment outcome:
low viral load, minimal liver disease progression and infection with HCV
genotypes 2 or 3 are all factors that predict a more favorable treatment
outcome. This report will focus on the overall sustained virological
response rate ((SVR) - undetectable HCV RNA or viral load achieved 24 weeks
post treatment) - as well as on the SVR based on genotype, viral load and
degree of HCV disease stage or progression. This is important since the
majority of people in the United States are infected with genotype 1 with a
high viral load, and these patients are considered the most difficult to
treat with current HCV medications.
High viral load is defined as over 2,000,000 copies; low viral load is
defined as under 2,000,000 copies.
Results: Genotype 1 - The Most Difficult to
Treat
The authors reported an overall 52% SVR for all genotype 1 patients, and the
study confirmed that the optimal dose of ribavirin is 1000-12000 mg/daily
with treatment duration of 48 weeks.
The study also analyzed the treatment outcome by low viral load (65% SVR)
and high viral load (47% SVR).
The authors further analyzed the SVR rates of patients according to the
extent of fibrosis at baseline and found that patients without cirrhosis
attained a 57% SVR versus 41% SVR for patients with cirrhosis or bridging
fibrosis.
Results: Genotypes 2 and 3
As expected the SVR rates for people infected with HCV genotypes 2 and 3
were much higher than those attained by genotype 1 patients. The study also
confirmed the results of previous Pegasys/Copegus studies that showed that a
24 week treatment duration and a ribavirin dose of 800 mg/daily produced the
optimal sustained virological response rate for people with genotypes 2 and
3. The overall SVR for genotypes 2 and 3 was 84%. Results based on viral
load were: 88% SVR for patients with genotypes 2 and 3, low viral load; and
82% SVR for patients with a high viral load.
The analysis by histology found that 87% of those patients without cirrhosis
or bridging fibrosis achieved an SVR, as opposed to 75% for those patients
with bridging fibrosis or cirrhosis.
Safety
The reported adverse events (side effects) were mild to moderate in severity
and were typical of those reported in previous clinical trials of Pegasys
plus Copegus.
Conclusion
The authors of this study concluded that the study demonstrated that
treatment with Pegasys plus Copegus may be individualized by genotype.
Key Points
Sustained virological response (SVR) rates:
• Overall SVR was 63%, which is the highest response rate ever re-ported in
a hepatitis C treatment clinical trial.
• Genotype 1 = 52% SVR.
• Genotype 1, high viral load = 47% SVR.
• Genotype 1, low viral load = 65% SVR.
• Genotypes 2 and 3 = 84% SVR.
• Genotypes 2 and 3, high viral load = 82% SVR.
• Genotypes 2 and 3, low viral load = 88% SVR.
Treatment Duration and ribavirin dosage:
• Genotype 1 - 48 weeks with ribavirin dose of 1000-1200 mg/day.
• Genotype 2 & 3 - 24 weeks with ribavirin dose of 800 mg/day.
www.hcvadvocate.com
|