|
Viral Kinetics Can
Predict Sustained Viral Response to Treatment with Pegasys and
Ribavirin, independent of Genotype, as Early as 1 or 4 Weeks of
Treatment
Early Hepatitis C viral (HCV) kinetics was previously shown to
predict sustained virological response (SVR). The current
consensus stopping rule is defined at 12 weeks of treatment with
peginterferon-alfa and ribavirin. Earlier prediction is needed
in order to improve the cost/effect ratio. However, the
predictive value of earlier viral kinetics for the current
standard of care has not yet been established.
The DITTO-HCV European funded project is for now the largest
study of frequent early viral kinetics during therapy with
peginterferon-alfa and ribavirin. The researchers aim to
optimize viral kinetics prediction criteria in order to enable
stopping or tailoring treatment as early as possible.
Primary objectives: 1) negative predictive value (NPV) as close
as possible to 100% (thus minimalizing stopped patients with
missed SVR), 2) high specificity (thus increasing the fraction
of patients that can be safely stopped). 3) a high positive
predictive value (PPV) using the same criteria.
134 chronically HCV infected naïve patients received
peginterferon-alfa-2a (40KD) (Pegasys ®) (180 μg qw) plus
ribavirin (Copegus ®) (1000-1200 mg qd) for 48 weeks. Of those,
67%, 28%, 4% and 1% had HCV genotype 1, 2-3, 4 or 5
respectively. Viral kinetics were measured according to
centralized serum HCV RNA quantifications on days 0, 1, 4, 7, 8,
15, 22 and 29 (Cobas Amplicor® HCV Monitor v2,
Roche). SVR was defined as undetectable serum HCV RNA (<50 IU/ml)
after 24 weeks of follow-up post treatment. The early viral
response prediction criteria (EVR) and thresholds tested here
(see Table 1 below) were prospectively defined.
Study
Results
The overall SVR rate was 64%. The EVR studied, together with
their NPV, PPV, specificity (SP), statistical significance and
number of HCV-RNA quantifications needed (NSMP), are given in
Table 1 below.
TABLE 1
|
EVR criteria definitions |
Week |
NSMP |
NPV |
SP |
PPV |
P |
N |
Week-12
(HCV RNA negative
and/or decline >2 log at week 12) |
12 |
2 |
100% |
21% |
68% |
0.001 |
128 |
2nd-slope
(2nd-slope at days 8-15-22-29
faster than 0.3 log/wk) |
4 |
3-5 |
<90% |
<40% |
<74% |
0.001 |
128 |
DITTO-2nd-slope
(combination of rapid slope between
days 8-29 and/or days 15-29) |
4 |
4 |
100% |
34% |
72% |
0.001 |
128 |
Week-1-decline
(Decline > 0.5 log at day 1, 4 or 7) |
1 |
2 |
<71% |
<37% |
<72% |
0.001 |
127 |
Week-1-VL
(VL < 5.5 log at day 1, 4 or 7) |
1 |
2 |
<77% |
<30% |
<70% |
0.004 |
127 |
DITTO-1st-week
(VL < 5.5 log on day 4
and/or decline > 0.5 log at day 7) |
1 |
3 |
100% |
28% |
70% |
0.001 |
127 |
The EVR-w12 criteria has good NPV (100%) but its specificity is
low (21%), thus relatively few non-responders can be stopped.
None of the simple 2nd-slope or Week-1 criteria shows NPV higher
than 90%, thus not adequate for a stopping rule.
A new composite criteria (DITTO-2nd-slp) gives NPV=100% and
specificity=34% already after 4 weeks of treatment. Furthermore,
another new composite criteria (DITTO-1st-week) also gives NPV=100%
with specificity=28% already after 1 week.
Although
composite, these new criteria are simple to calculate and
necessitate only 1 or 2 more viral quantifications compared to
the current Week-12 criteria. Thus allowing to lower the mean
cost by 2410 USD per patient. Note that SVR (56% for gen 1 and
87% for gen 2-3) is predicted independently of genotype.
Moreover, by selecting more strict thresholds for the
DITTO-1st-week (e.g. 4.5 log at day 4 and 2 log decline at day
7) and DITTO-2nd-slope (e.g, 0.6 log/week) criteria one can
obtain higher PPV up to 90%.
Conclusions:
Sustained viral response to treatment with peginterferon-alfa-2a
(40KD) and ribavirin can be predicted, independent of genotype,
as early as 1 or 4 weeks of treatment by new composite, but
still simple and practical, criteria of viral kinetics. Similar
NPV and PPV and better specificity was obtained here by the
DITTO-1st-week or DITTO-2nd-slope prediction criteria, giving
rise to significantly lower cost/effect as compared to the
current stopping rule at 12 weeks. These results warrant future
prospective testing in larger trials, since they can give rise
to considerable saving in cost and quality of life related to
over-treatment or alternatively allow early tailoring of
treatment.
Discussion
Can the new
predictive criteria move the current 12- week stopping rule to
under a month?
The DITTO-HCV
study retrospectively identified two new criteria to classify
rapid viral responders and predict the likely treatment outcome.
For the DITTO-1st week criterion viral levels are
measured at baseline and two times in the first week of
treatment; while the DITTO-2nd slope criterion uses
three measurements of viral levels between the second and fourth
week of treatment.
“Both of these
new criteria predicted who was and who was not likely to respond
to treatment more accurately than the existing 12-week stopping
rule. We had obtained 100 per cent negative predictive value (NPV)
and 90 per cent positive predictive value (PPV) with these
criteria” said
Professor
Avidan
Neumann, from the Bar-Ilan University, Israel, and the DITTO-HCV
study coordinator who presented the study results at an oral
session at AASLD.
Using these
criteria for stopping treatment in patients predicted early on
not to respond will make treatment more cost-effective, even
considering the added cost of the extra measurements of viral
load.
“This is
good news for patients and physicians. Using these new
criteria, we will be able to very early, identify more of those
patients who will ultimately not achieve an SVR so we can advise
them to stop taking their medication, thus improving their
quality of life,” said
Professor
Neumann.
“We now know
that tailoring treatment according to viral kinetics cannot
improve SVR rates with the treatment choices we have at the
moment. However, by measuring viral levels earlier in
treatment, a test physicians are already familiar with, we can
likely move the stopping rule currently defined at week 12 down
to week 4 or even week 1 and avoid having patients who will not
achieve an SVR being treated unnecessarily. These novel
prediction algorithms will hopefully be confirmed soon by other
clinical trials and their feasibility in clinical practice will
be assessed, thus allowing us to optimize the treatment of
hepatitis C patients," concluded Prof. Neumann.
10/27/03
Reference
AU Neumann and others. EARLY VIRAL KINETICS PREDICTION OF
SUSTAINED VIROLOGICAL RESPONSE AFTER 1 OR 4 WEEKS OF
PEG-INTERFERON-ALFA-2A AND RIBAVIRIN THERAPY (DITTO-HCV
PROJECT).
Pegasys/Ribavirin Treatment in African
American and Caucasians with Chronic HCV Genotype 1
Background:
Response rates to interferon (IFN) therapy appear to be lower in
African American (AA) patients with chronic hepatitis C than in
Caucasians (Ca). The lower response has been attributed, in
part, to the high prevalence of infection with hepatitis C virus
(HCV) genotype 1 among the AA population. However, low numbers
of AA patients in prospective clinical trials has hampered
meaningful evaluation of antiviral therapy.
The objective
of this study was to determine the efficacy and safety of
Pegasys (peginterferon alfa-2a/40KD) in combination with
ribavirin (RBV) in non-Hispanic AA HCV genotype 1 patients.
The trial
enrolled patients in a 3:1 ratio of AA to Ca patients and was
powered only to estimate sustained virologic response (SVR) in
the AA group to within ± 10% of a 95% confidence interval.
Patients with
previously untreated chronic HCV genotype 1 and elevated ALT
received Pegasys 180 µg sc once weekly plus RBV 1000 or 1200 mg
orally based on body weight (<75 kg or >75 kg) for 48
weeks, with 24 weeks of treatment-free follow-up. High viral
load (HVL) was defined as HCV RNA >1 X 106 IU/mL.
Early
virologic response (EVR) at 12 weeks of therapy (defined as HCV
RNA <50 IU/mL, or >2-log10 drop in HCV RNA from
baseline) was assessed. SVR was defined as undetectable HCV RNA
at week 72; sustained biochemical response (SBR) was defined as
normal serum ALT at Week 72.
Histologic
responses were reported as Knodell HAI scores of liver biopsies
obtained prior to treatment and within 4 weeks of completion of
the 24-week untreated follow-up period.
Study Results
A total of 106
patients received at least one dose of study medication.
Baseline characteristics of AA patients were: mean age 46 years,
56 male (72 %), mean ALT 63 U/L, high viral load 45 (58%).
Baseline
characteristics of Ca patients were: mean age 45 years, 17 male
(61%), mean ALT 64 U/L, high viral load 12 (43%). Sixty-two of
78 (80%) AA patients and 22 of 28 (79%) Ca patients completed
treatment. The table below shows an SVR rate of 26% for AA
patients and 39% for Ca patients.
A larger
proportion, 45 of 78 AA patients had high viral loads prior to
the initiation of therapy, contrasting with only 12 of 28 Ca
patients.
SVR was
achieved by 9 (20%) and 3 (25%) of patients with HVL in each
group respectively. Of 47 AA patients who had EVRs, 20 patients
went on to achieve an SVR.
The negative
predictive value of EVR was 100% for both AAs and Cas. SBR was
observed with similar frequency for both racial groups (36% for
AA and 39% for Ca). Histologic analyses of a subgroup of
patients for whom paired biopsies were available showed that 13
of 53 (25%) AA patients and 1 of 16 (6%) Ca patients had
fibrosis improvement. No unexpected adverse events (AEs)
occurred during the study. Four of 78 (5%) AA patients and 4 of
28 (14%) Ca patients withdrew prematurely for AEs or laboratory
abnormalities.
Conclusions
The SVR of 26%
in AA with genotype 1 HCV after therapy with Pegasys plus RBV is
the highest response to combination therapy yet reported in this
population. The SVR rate in the AA population is nonetheless
lower than in other studies with patients of diverse ethnic
backgrounds and may be explained by the higher viral titers
observed in these patients. Failure to achieve EVR has a high
negative predictive value for SVR with continuing therapy.
This study
demonstrates that Pegasys with RBV is a safe and tolerable
treatment for AA patients with chronic HCV genotype 1 infection.
In addition, the SVR rate and histologic benefit observed in
this trial provide a basis for future efforts to increase
efficacy in this difficult to treat population .
Summary of Efficacy Analyses
|
Response
Variable |
African
Americans
(n=78) |
Caucasians
(n=28) |
Sustained
virological response (SVR)
Number (%)
95% CI for percentage with response |
20 (26%)
16 - 35% |
11 (39%)
21 – 57% |
Sustained
biochemical response (SBR)
Number (%)
95% CI for percentage with response |
28 (36%)
25 - 46% |
11 (39%)
21 – 57% |
Louisiana
State University Health Sciences Center, University of Maryland
School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Roche
Laboratories, Inc., Nutley, NJ.
10/27/03
Reference
LJ
Jeffers and others. Peginterferon Alfa-2a (40KD) (Pegasys®)
in Combination with Ribavirin in African American and Caucasian
Patients with Chronic Hepatitis C Virus Genotype 1: Results of a
Multicenter Study. Abstract 71 (oral).
54th AASLD. October 24-28, 2003. Boston, MA.
Pegasys/Ribavirin Enhances HCV
Specific T-cell Responses by Restoration of Dendritic Cell
Functions
Pegasys (peginterferon
alfa-2a/40KD)/ribavirin combination therapy markedly improves
the sustained virological response in chronic hepatitis C
compared to conventional interferon alfa therapy.
This research
group has previously demonstrated that Pegasys alone or in
combination with ribavirin enhances HCV specific CD4+ T helper 1
responses in patients with chronic hepatitis C but the
underlying mechanism by which the HCV-specific responses are
restored is not yet fully understood.
Dendritic
cells (DCs) are the most efficient type of cells involved in
antigen presentation (APC), however HCV proteins
affect DC function resulting in abnormal priming of
anti-HCV-specific T cells and defective antiviral immunity. The
investigators hypothesized that peginterferon activates CD4+
T cells through restoration of the DC
antigen-presenting function.
Monocyte-derived
dendritic cells (DCs) generation (magnatic sorting and positive
selection), phenotypic analysis and allogeneic stimulatory
capacity of DC (S.I.) as well as HCV-specific CD4+ T-cell
proliferative responses and cytokine production to HCV proteins
(ELISPOT assay using autologous DCs as APCs) were prospectively
assessed in 64 patients with chronic
hepatitis C (genotypes 1 and 4) before, during and after
treatment with either conventional
IFN-alfa-2a therapy, or
Pegasys/ribavirin
combination therapy and the results were correlated to the
therapy outcome.
Study Results
The SVR
in genotype 1 was 49% with
Pegasys/ribavirin, and 26% with conventional IFN alfa-2a
ribavirin while in genotype 4 the SVR was 54% in
subjects treated with Pegasys/ribavirin
combination therapy vs 28% of HCV in subjects treated
with conventional IFN alfa-2a/ribavirin.
Before
induction of therapy, DCs from HCV infected subjects exhibited a
pattern of incomplete activation and the stimulatory
capacity of HCV-DCs was significantly lower than that of the
normal-DCs (7.8± 3.9 vs. 67.2± 19.7, respectively; P < 0.001)
The same
pattern of incomplete activation was observed in CD4+
T cells in the form of absent or weak
pre-treatment HCV specific CD4+ responses. Initiation
of Pegasys/ ribavirin therapy markedly ameliorated the
allostimulatory capacity in DCs of HCV patients and induced
significant increase in the frequency, strength and breadth
of HCV-specific CD4+T-h1
responses; compared to conventional IFN-alfa-2a-based
regimen.
The
stimulatory capacity of HCV-DC was restored to normal in
subjects who achieved SVR (62.05 ± 17.7 in SR
versus 11.88 ± 2.55 in NR; P = 0.007).
Sustained
responders developed early
restoration of DC functions and strong multi-specific persistent
HCV specific CD4+T- cell responses with preferential IFN-γ
production and IL-10 suppression. Interestingly patients who had
breakthrough or relapse had transient increase in DC stimulatory
capacity, which coincided with the absence of HCV viremia;
however DC abnormalities were detected with recurrence of
viremia.
Viral
clearance and HAI improvement but not HCV genotype correlated
with the DC stimulatory capacity and HCV-specific CD4+
responses.
The authors conclude, “Pegasys
in combination with ribavirin enhances HCV specific
CD4+
T responses through restoration of the antigen presenting
functions of dendritic cells. This finding has important
implications for development of novel immunotherapeutic
strategies.
Harvard Institutes Of Medicine, Boston, Ma, USA, University Of
Freiburg, Germany, Ain Shams University, Egypt.
10/26/03
Reference
SM
Kamal and others. PEGINTERFERON a-2A
(40KD) ENHANCES HCV SPECIFIC T-CELL RESPONSES BY RESTORATION OF
ALLOSTIMULATORY FUNCTION of DENDRITIC CELL FUNCTIONS IN CHRONIC
HEPATITIS C. Abstract 63 (oral). 54th AASLD. October
24-28, 2003. Boston, MA.
Preliminary Data Do Not Support
Hypothesis That Higher SVR Rates in Genotype 1 HCV Patients
Result from Extending Treatment from 48 to 72 Weeks
Treatment of
patients infected with hepatitis C virus (HCV) genotype 1 (G1)
remains a challenge necessitating innovative strategies to
improve treatment outcome. Viral kinetic studies have shown that
turnover of hepatocytes infected with HCV G1 is slower than in
other genotypes. This implies that more aggressive antiviral
treatments are required in patients infected with HCV G1.
Extending the treatment duration beyond 48 weeks is one strategy
that may improve response rates in these difficult-to-treat
patients.
The purpose of the current study was to compare the efficacy and
safety of 48 weeks versus 72 weeks of treatment with
peginterferon alfa-2a (40KD) (PEGASYS) in combination with
ribavirin (COPEGUS) in treatment-naïve patients infected with
HCV G1.
This multicenter, national, randomized, open-label parallel
group study was conducted in accordance with local and
international GCP guidelines. Treatment-naïve patients infected
with HCV G1, aged ≥18 years with CHC infection, HCV RNA levels
>1000 copies/mL, elevated ALT levels, liver biopsy findings
consistent with a diagnosis of CHC, and compensated liver
disease (Child-Pugh grade A) were eligible for the study.
After screening and signing of informed consent forms, patients
were randomized to treatment with peginterferon alfa-2a (40KD) (PEGASY)
180 μg once weekly plus ribavirin (COPEGUS) 800 mg/day (400 mg
BID) for either 48 weeks or 72 weeks. Patients were followed for
an additional 24 weeks after the end of treatment. Virological
response was defined as undetectable HCV RNA (<50 IU/mL by COBAS
AMPLICOR HCV Test, v2.0, Roche Diagnostics) at the end of
follow-up.
To date
459 patients have been enrolled in the trial and 305 have
completed follow-up. The two treatment groups were comparable
with regard to baseline characteristics. The results of the
study, presented as intent-to-treat, missing data = failure
(ITT; M=F), and on-treatment (OT) analysis (only patients with
data included) are captured in the Table 1 below.
No major differences were observed in the frequency or intensity
of SAEs and AEs.
Conclusions
The combination of peginterferon alfa-2a (40KD) (PEGASYS) and
ribavirin (COPEGUS) was safe and effective in patients with HCV
genotype 1. Despite the use of a dose of ribavirin (800 mg/day)
that is lower than the recommended dose for patients infected
with G1 (1000/1200 mg/day), approximately half of the patients
in the study achieved an SVR.
Because the study could not be blinded, a bias might have
influenced the outcome of the study as suggested by the unequal
discontinuation rate. These preliminary data do not support the
hypothesis that higher SVR rates can be achieved in patients
with HCV G1 by extending treatment duration.
| |
48 weeks
of treatment |
72 weeks
of treatment |
Patients with HCV RNA<50 IU/ml
(%)*
|
| |
ITT; M=F
(n = 221) |
OT
(n = 221) |
ITT; M=F
(n = 215) |
OT
(n = 215) |
|
Treatment wk 12 |
119/221 (54) |
119/207 (58) |
109/215 (51) |
109/197 (55) |
|
Treatment wk 24 |
149/221 (67) |
149/203 (73) |
137/215 (64) |
137/202 (68) |
|
Treatment wk 48 |
141/221 (64) |
142/169 (84) |
131/215 (61) |
131/156 (84) |
|
Treatment wk 72 |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
115/215 (54) |
115/140 (82) |
|
Follow-up wk 12 |
113/221 (51) |
113/192 (59) |
97/215 (42) |
97/167 (58) |
|
Follow-up wk 24 |
107/221 (48) |
107/181 (59) |
90/215 (42) |
90/157 (57) |
|
Discontinuation for any reason** |
|
Overall (%) |
58/231 (25.1) |
93/225 (41.3) |
|
Before wk 48 (%) |
56/231 (24.2) |
53/225 (23.6) |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
*ITT population, defined as all patients who took at least
one dose of study medication and had at least one HCV RNA
evaluation post-baseline.
**Safety population, defined as all patients who took at least
one dose of the study medication.
10/27/03
Reference
T Berg
and others (German Pegasys + Copegus Genotype 1 HCV Study
Group).
COMPARISON OF 48 OR 72 WEEKS OF TREATMENT WITH PEGINTERFERON
ALFA-2A (40KD) (PEGASYS®) PLUS RIBAVIRIN (COPEGUS®)
IN TREATMENT-NAÏVE PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC HEPATITIS C INFECTED
WITH HCV GENOTYPE 1. Abstract 328 (poster). 54th
AASLD. October 24-28, 2003. Boston, MA.
Subjects with Chronic Hepatitis C and
Genotype 4 Have a Similarly Effective Response to Standard or
Pegylated Interferon in Combination with Ribavirin
The prevalence
of HCV infection in Egypt varies between 9% and 24% and
approximately 90% are infected with HCV genotype 4.To date
limited data exist on the effect of antiviral therapy on
genotype 4-infected subjects.
The purpose of
this study was to assess the effect of interferon (standard or
pegylated) in combination with ribavirin in naïve-to-treatment
subjects with chronic hepatitis C who reside in Egypt.
In a
prospective, open-label, randomized clinical trial, 200 Egyptian
subjects with chronic hepatitis C documented by liver biopsy and
detectable HCV RNA in serum received interferon alfa 2b
(IFN-a2b) 3 MU TIW or pegylated IFN-a 2b (100 mcg/week) in
combination with weight-based oral ribavirin (800 or 1000 mg for
both groups).
The study
design was that if HCV RNA was detectable at week 24, the
treatment was stopped but if HCV RNA was undetectable at week
24, treatment was extended for a total of 48 weeks. Subjects
were observed for an additional 24 weeks and HCV RNA status at
week 72 determined the response to antiviral therapy.
Safety
laboratory tests were done at regular intervals. The study
received IRB approval. The HCV RNA was done by a PCR technique
with a detectability cutoff of 50-copies/ml.
Study
Results
Both
randomized groups were similar at baseline without statistical
significant difference, 190 (90%) were infected with genotype 4,
mean age was 39.5 years ± 8.7 years, 158 were men (79%), mean
BMI was 27.8 ± 4 kg/m2, mean inflammatory HAI score
was 7/18 ± 2 and fibrosis stage 2.7/6 ± 1.3.
Of the 190
genotype-4 infected individuals, 156 have finished therapy (week
48) and 78 had completed the 24-week follow-up (week 72). The
study will be completed by October 2003. The table shows the
intention to treat rates of undetectable HCV RNA in genotype-4
infected subjects.
Serious
adverse events that led to discontinuation of medications were
observed in 6 subjects in the standard IFN/RBV group and in
11subjects in the PEG IFN/RBV, one death was observed in the
latter group. Expected adverse events were observed in similar
rates in both groups.
Laboratory
adverse events were observed between 2% and 10% of subjects
receiving either treatment regimen depending on the week of
therapy. No growth factors were used in this population.
Conclusions
Subjects with
chronic hepatitis C and genotype-4 infection have a similar
antiviral response to standard or pegylated interferon in
combination with ribavirin. The safety and tolerability of the
medications is similar to what has been observed for other HCV
genotypes. Patients infected with HCV genotype 4 respond
effectively to therapy and should be encouraged to undergo
antiviral treatment.
|
Negative
HCV RNA by Study Group |
| |
IFN a-2b/RBV
|
PEG IFN/RBV
|
'p' value |
|
Week 48 |
41/75 (55%) |
46/83 (55%) |
1.0 |
|
Week 72 |
15/38 (39%) |
16/40 (40%) |
1.0 |
10/27/03
Reference
GH
Esmat and others. RESULTS OF A RANDOMIZED CLINICAL TRIAL OF
GENOTYPE-4 INFECTED SUBJECTS WHEN TREATED WITH STANDARD OR
PEGYLATED INTERFERON alfa-2b IN COMBINATION WITH RIBAVIRIN.
Abstract 324. 54th AASLD. October 24-28, 2003.
Boston, MA.
Rapid Viral Decline with Pegasys/Ribavirin in
HCV Genotype 1 Is Associated with Enhanced HCV-specific T-cell
Reactivity
Treatment of
patients with chronic HCV infection with HCV genotype 1 (GT 1)
remains a significant challenge, with patients infected with
this genotype having significantly lower rates of response to
therapy relative to patients infected with genotypes 2 or 3. The
reasons for this poor treatment response are not well understood
and therapeutic optimization requires an understanding of the
differences in viral dynamics and immune reactivity during
therapy.
In a study
presented at the 54th AASLD Conference, investigators
analyzed early HCV kinetics during Pegasys (peginterferon-alfa
2a) plus ribavirin treatment and their relationships with both
cellular and humoral immune responses in 30, treatment-naïve,
non-cirrhotic, GT 1 infected patients.
The
investigators found that at treatment week (TW) 4, 19/30 (63%)
patients showed >2 log10 copies/mL reduction from
baseline viral load and 28/30 (93%) patients achieved >2 log10
copies/mL reduction in viral load at TW 12.
Mathematical
modeling of serial plasma viral load measurements clearly
differentiated two subgroups - rapid (19/30) and slow/flat
(11/30) treatment-responders over the first 4 weeks of antiviral
treatment.
The novel
triphasic pattern of HCV decay was found in 10/19 (52%) rapid
responders, and 5/11 (45%) of slow/flat responders. The phase 1
viral decline and infected hepatocyte clearance were
significantly higher in rapid, compared to slow/flat responders.
Anti-E1 levels
decreased by 22% between baseline and TW 4 with no significant
differences between rapid vs slow/flat responders. Baseline
gamma GT and TW 4 viral load were significantly lower in rapid
versus slow/flat responders (p<0.05).
Based upon
these data, the authors conclude, “This study reveals marked
differences in early viral kinetic profiles amongst [GT 1]
patients treated with peginterferon-alfa 2a and ribavirin. Rapid
viral decline after starting treatment is associated with
enhanced HCV-specific T-cell reactivity. HCV dynamics and
associated immune reactivity during therapy enables optimization
of treatment regimens in patients with [GT 1] infection.”
Reference
K Tang and others. RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN EARLY VIRAL KINETICS AND
IMMUNE REACTIVITY IN CHRONIC HEPATITIS C (GENOTYPE 1) PATIENTS
TREATED WITH PEGINTERFERON-ALFA 2A AND RIBAVIRIN. Abstract 191
(oral). Program and Abstracts of the 54th Annual
Meeting of the American Association for the Study of Liver
Diseases. October 24-28, 2003. Boston, MA.
Combination Treatment with Pegasys and Copegus
Significantly Enhances Sustained Virological and Biochemical
Response Rates in Patients with Chronic Hepatitis C Genotype 4
Hepatitis C genotype 4 accounts for 60 to 90% of HCV chronic
infections in the Eastern Mediterranean region but this is rare
in other parts of the world. Earlier studies have reported poor
treatment response rates for conventional interferons (IFN) with
HCV genotype 4.
The advent of pegylated IFN and its success with other genotypes
was our motivation for the current study. The objective was to
determine and compare the efficacy and safety of Pegasys (peginterferon
alfa-2a) plus ribavirin with Pegasys monotherapy and Roferon A (IFN
alfa-2a) plus ribavirin combination therapy in the treatment of
chronic hepatitis C genotype 4 patients in Saudi Arabia.
This open label multicenter clinical enrolled 180 patients
infected with chronic hepatitis C genotype 4. These patients
were randomized into treatment groups (1:1:1) as follows:
GROUP A: Pegasys 180micrograms qw plus ribavirin (400mg) bid.
GROUP B: Pegasys 80 micrograms qw.
GROUP C: Roferon 4.5MIU tiw plus ribavirin (400mg) bid.
Treatment duration was for 48 weeks with follow up period of 24
weeks.
Study
Results
Early virological response (2-log drop or HCV-RNA clearance) at
week 12 was 77%, 60% and 43% in groups A, B and C, respectively.
End of treatment response (week 48) for the groups were 67%, 59%
and 37%.
Sustained virological responses (week 72) were 50%, 28% and 30%
respectively.
Among week 12 early responders the sustained virological
responses were 65.2% and 47.2% in the two-pegylated IFN groups
and the sustained biochemical response was 69.6% and 69.4%.
Twelve
patients (6.7%) dropped out of the study as follows: group A, 7
patients (11.7%), group B, 4 (6.7%) and group C, 1 (1.7%). These
were various adverse events ranging from alopecia, thyroiditis,
oesophageal varices, tonic convulsion, encephalopathy and
depression. Interestingly 5 of the 12 patients had early
virological response.
Conclusions
a) A 100% negative predictive value among non-responders was
observed for all treatment groups at early virological response
at week 12.
b) Despite the use of a low dose ribavirin of 400mg bid, an
enhanced sustained virological response of 50% (65% in early
responders) was determined for the combination of peginterferon
alfa-2a plus ribavirin.
c) A comparatively low relapse rate was observed in patients
treated with peginterferon alfa-2a plus ribavirin.
d) Patients infected with HCV genotype 4 can be safely and
effectively treated with Pegasys plus Copegus (ribavirin).
11/05/03
Reference
OA Shobokshi COMBINATION THERAPY OF PEGINTERFERON ALFA-2A (40KD)
(PEGASYS®) AND RIBAVIRIN (COPEGUS®) SIGNIFICANTLY ENHANCE
SUSTAINED VIROLOGICAL AND BIOCHEMICAL RESPONSE RATE IN CHRONIC
HEPATITIS C GENOTYPE 4 PATIENTS IN SAUDI ARABIA. Abstract 996
(poster).
54th
Annual Meeting of the American Association for the Study of
Liver Diseases. October 24-28, 2003. Boston, MA
Pegasys Plus Ribavirin
Demonstrates Good Safety and Tolerability Profiles in African
Americans with Chronic HCV Genotype 1
Interferon alfa therapy, alone or in combination with ribavirin
(RBV), is less effective for chronic hepatitis C genotype 1
infections in African Americans (AA) compared with Caucasian
Americans (Ca). Racial differences in tolerability and adherence
to antiviral therapy have not been studied systematically.
Several studies on treatment of African Americans with chronic
HCV genotype 1 were presented at the 53rd AASLD in
Boston (October 24-28, 2003).
The aim of the current study was to evaluate the safety and
tolerability of peginterferon alfa-2a (40KD) when used in
combination with ribavirin in non-Hispanic AA HCV genotype 1
patients.
Patients with previously untreated chronic hepatitis with HCV
genotype 1 and elevated ALT were evaluated. Patients received
Pegasys (peginterferon alfa-2a) 180 microgram subcutaneous (sc)
once weekly plus RBV 1000 or 1200 mg orally based on body weight
(<75 kg or >75 kg) for 48 weeks, with 24 weeks of
treatment-free follow-up.
Efficacy was assessed by sustained virologic response (SVR),
defined as undetectable HCV RNA (<50 IU/mL) at week 72. Adverse
events (AEs) reported by patients and clinical laboratory test
results were used to assess tolerability and safety.
Study Results
A total of 106 patients received at least one dose of study
medication. Of patients completing treatment, 62 of 78 (80%)
were AA and 22 of 28 (79%) were Ca. The SVR rate (26%) was lower
among AA patients than among Ca patients (39%). The most
frequent AEs reported included headache, fatigue, rigors,
insomnia, nausea, myalgia, arthralgia, pyrexia, depression,
dizziness, irritability, dyspnea and injection site erythema;
most reported at a higher frequency by Ca than by AA.
Serious AEs occurred in 9% (7 of 78) of AA patients and in 25%
(7 of 28) of Ca patients; however, only 3 were considered to be
treatment-related by the investigators (thrombocytopenia, upper
abdominal pain and possibly hydronephrosis).
AA patients had lower baseline absolute neutrophil counts (ANC)
(AA 2.9 ± 0.15 x 109/L vs. Ca 3.5 ± 0.19 x 109/L).
Reductions in ANC by 45% for AAs were observed after one week of
therapy, sustained during treatment, and returned to
pretreatment levels early in the follow-up period. A gradual 51%
decline in ANC occurred by week 6 for the Ca patients. The ANC
nadir for AA was 1.6 + 0.09 x 109/L, similar
to that for Cas, 1.7 + 0.10 x 109/L.
Similar results on treatment and during follow-up were observed
for hemoglobin (Hb) and platelet counts. Hb levels decreased to
to <8.5 g/dL in 4 (5%) AA patients and 2 (7%) Ca patients.
Platelet counts <50 x 109/L (not associated with
bleeding-related adverse events) were evident in 3 (4%) AA
patients and 1 (4%) Ca patient. Dose modifications of Pegasys
(withheld or reduced) occurred among 46% AAs and 29% Cas; the
most common indication was neutropenia (37% and 18% among AAs
and Cas, respectively). RBV dose modifications occurred for 40%
of AAs and 46% of Cas, primarily due to anemia.
Few patients withdrew prior to the end of treatment at week 48
for AEs or laboratory abnormalities, 4 of 78 (5%) in the AA
group and 4 of 28 (14%) in the Ca group.
Discontinuations due to hematologic suppression were as follows:
1 AA patient for neutropenia, 1 AA patient for anemia and 1 Ca
patient for thrombocytopenia.
One AA patient died as a result of an acute anterior myocardial
infarction 180 days after receipt of the last dose of RBV. The
death was considered to be unrelated to treatment by the
investigator.
Large majorities of both groups, 67 (86%) of AA patients and 25
(89%) of the Ca patients demonstrated 80% adherence to the
therapeutic regimen, calculated as total cumulative dose/total
original dose prescribed, indicating that compliance was similar
between racial groups.
Conclusions
Pegasys plus RBV demonstrated good
safety and tolerability in AA patients in this trial. While dose
modifications for neutropenia and anemia were conducted
according to protocol, hematologic suppression had minimal
effects on overall adherence to therapy. Adverse events were
generally mild.
11/03/03
Reference
C Howell and others. PEGINTERFERON ALFA-2A (40KD) (PEGASYS®)
IN COMBINATION WITH RIBAVIRIN IN AFRICAN AMERICAN AND CAUCASIAN
PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC HEPATITIS C HCV GENOTYPE 1: SAFETY AND
TOLERABILITY. Abstract 332 (poster).
54th
Annual Meeting of the American Association for the Study of
Liver Diseases. October 24-28, 2003. Boston, MA.
Pegasys Plus Ribavirin
Produces a Benefit Regarding Histologic Response Among African
Americans and Caucasians with Chronic HCV Genotype 1
Chronic hepatitis due to hepatitis
C virus (HCV) is common among African Americans (AA) and HCV
genotype 1 accounts for approximately 90% of HCV infections in
these individuals. Virologic response rates to interferon (IFN)
therapy in AA patients with chronic HCV infection have been
reported to be lower than that for Caucasians (Ca), but the
effect of therapy on hepatic histology in AA patients remains to
be assessed.
The objective of this open label study was to evaluate
histologic progression of disease in conjunction with anti-viral
efficacy and safety in non-Hispanic AA HCV genotype 1 patients
and non-Hispanic Ca, HCV genotype 1 patients treated with
Pegasys (peginterferon alfa-2a/40KD) in combination with
ribavirin (RBV).
A multicenter study was conducted to evaluate the efficacy and
safety of the combination of Pegasys and RBV in AA patients and
in Ca patients. All patients were required to have previously
untreated chronic HCV genotype 1 infection, elevated ALT levels
and. a liver biopsy obtained within the 24 months prior to
enrollment demonstrating chronic hepatitis but without
cirrhosis.
Patients received Pegasys 180 microgram sc once weekly plus RBV
1000 or 1200 mg orally based on body weight (<75 kg or =75 kg)
for 48 weeks, with 24 weeks of treatment-free follow-up.
Histologic responses based on the Knodell HAI score were
determined from liver biopsies obtained prior to treatment and
within 4 weeks of completion of the 24-week untreated follow-up
period. HAI activity scores range from 0-18 and fibrosis scores
range from 0-4. The histology outcome was evaluated for patients
with paired biopsies only.
Improvement in necroinflammatory activity was defined as >2
point decrease, and improvement in fibrosis as > 1 point
decrease. The primary efficacy endpoint was sustained virologic
response (SVR) with undetectable HCV RNA (<50 IU/mL) at 72
weeks.
Study Results
The intent-to-treat population included 106 patients. Paired
biopsies were available for 53 of the 78 AA patients and 16 of
the 28 Ca patients. These patients were representative of all
patients with respect to Knodell HAI scores.
Mean baseline HAI activity scores were 7.2 + 0.32 for AA
and 6.9 + 0.69 for Ca patients; mean baseline fibrosis
scores were 1.8 + 0.14 and 1.9 + 0.3, respectively. The SVR rate
for all AA patients was 20/78 (26%) and for all Ca patients,
11/28 (39%).
For those patients with paired biopsies, SVR rates were 17/53
(32%) in AA patients and 10/16 (63%) in Ca patients. The
majority of patients in both groups exhibited improvement in
activity scores: 64% for the AA group and 69% for the Ca group.
More importantly, the table below shows that the proportion of
patients with worsening fibrosis was similar in both groups,
while 13/53 (25%) of AA patients and only 1/ 16 (6%) of Ca
patients showed fibrosis improvement. Mean changes in fibrosis
scores were -0.4 ± 0.14 for AA and -0.1 ± 0.14 for Ca patients.
Among AA patients who had paired biopsies, 5/17 (29%) patients
who achieved SVR had fibrosis improvement; and 8/36 (22.2%)
viral non-responders exhibited fibrosis improvement. The only
patient who had fibrosis improvement among Ca was a viral
non-responder.
Conclusions
Therapy with Pegasys plus RBV produced improvement in necro-inflammation
and fibrosis in a substantial group of AA patients in this
study. Although the SVR of 26% in AA with genotype 1 HCV is the
highest response to combination therapy yet reported in this
population, even patients without an SVR achieved a benefit with
regard to hepatic histology.
|
Changes in
liver histology after treatment with peginterferon alfa-2a
(40KD) |
Category
|
AA n=53
Number (%) |
Ca n=16
Number (%) |
|
Improved (1-3 point decrease) |
13 (25) |
1 (6) |
|
Stable |
36 (69) |
14 (88) |
|
Worsened (1-3 point increase) |
4 (8) |
1 (6) |
11/03/03
Reference
W Cassidy and others. PEGINTERFERON ALFA-2A (40KD) (PEGASYS®)
IN COMBINATION WITH RIBAVIRIN IN AFRICAN AMERICAN AND CAUCASIAN
PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC HEPATITIS C VIRUS GENOTYPE 1 INFECTION:
ASSESSMENT OF HISTOLOGIC RESPONSE. Abstract 307 (poster).
54th
Annual Meeting of the American Association for the Study of
Liver Diseases. October 24-28, 2003. Boston, MA.
Daily and Higher Initial Dosing of Consensus
Interferon (Infergen) May Be a Worthwhile Alternative to
Peginterferon + Ribavirin in Genotype 1 HCV Patients with High
HCV RNA
Treatment with pegylated interferon alfa and ribavirin has an
efficacy in chronic hepatitis C patients with sustained response
rates of about 50%. However, response in genotype 1 patients
with high viral load is considerably lower and is not
significantly improved by pegylation of interferon.
In the present study, conducted at the University of Tubingen,
Germany, the efficacy of consensus interferon (CIFN) daily
dosing and induction therapy followed by combination with
ribavirin in 200 naive patients with chronic hepatitis C and
genotype 1 was evaluated.
All patients had histologically proven hepatitis, elevated ALT
values and were viremic, the average weight was 80 kg. Patients
were treated with CIFN dosages of 27 or 18 ug QD for 4 weeks,
followed by 18 or 9 ug QD for 8 weeks. Treatment was continued
with CIFN at 9 ug QD with ribavirin (7.5 or 15 mg/kg/d) for
another 36 weeks.
Study
Results
At 48 weeks therapy an undetectable HCV-RNA was observed in 79 %
and 72 % in the CIFN 27/18 and 18/9 ug groups, respectively.
Data regarding sustained response rates showed 64% and 58% for
CIFN 27/18 and 18/9 ug groups, respectively. Due to side effects
CIFN had to be dose reduced in 11% and discontinued in 6% of
patients.
Addition of ribavirin potentiated the effect of consensus
interferon in a dose-dependent manner as has been shown for
other interferons previously.
When viral response rates were related to the initial viral
load, in the genotype 1 / low viral load group, SR rates of 71
and 74% were obtained for the CIFN 27/18 and 18/9 ug groups
(diff. n.s.). In contrast, genotype 1 / high viral load patients
showed SR rates for the CIFN 27/18 and CIFN 18/9 ug groups of 41
and 49% (diff. sig.), respectively. The viral response rates
obtained with daily dosing of CIFN were significantly higher
than an independently run control arm using CIFN at 9 ug TIW
with ribavirin irrespective of the initial viral load.
Four patients (2%) experienced grade III thrombocytopenias,
while no grade IV neutropenias or thrombocytopenias were
observed. The overall tolerability in the CIFN 18/9 ug QD arm
was comparable to standard therapy with pegylated interferon a2b
and ribavirin, while the CIFN 27/18/9 ug arm was less tolerable
during the high dosing period. However, the withdrawal rates
were not significantly affected by the higher dose of CIFN.
Conclusions
CIFN daily dosing / induction therapy in combination with
ribavirin thus shows significant response rates with the highest
response rates in genotype 1 patients seen to-date. The
sustained response rates for genotype 1 / high viral load
patients are higher than the ones demonstrated in the PEG
Interferon and ribavirin registration trials. These data suggest
that for difficult-to-treat genotype 1 / high viral load
patients CIFN with daily and higher initial dosing may be a
worthwhile alternative to standard combination therapy with
pegylated interferons.
11/07/03
Reference
S Kaiser and others. DAILY DOSING REGIMEN OF CONSENSUS
INTERFERON AND RIBAVIRIN FOR TREATMENT-NAIVE PATIENTS WITH
CHRONIC HEPATITIS C AND GENOTYPE 1. Abstract 304 (poster).
54th
Annual Meeting of the American Association for the Study of
Liver Diseases. October 24-28, 2003. Boston, MA.
|