|
Viral Kinetics Can
Predict Sustained Viral Response to Treatment with Pegasys and
Ribavirin, independent of Genotype, as Early as 1 or 4 Weeks of
Treatment
Early Hepatitis C viral (HCV) kinetics was previously shown to
predict sustained virological response (SVR). The current
consensus stopping rule is defined at 12 weeks of treatment with
peginterferon-alfa and ribavirin. Earlier prediction is needed
in order to improve the cost/effect ratio. However, the
predictive value of earlier viral kinetics for the current
standard of care has not yet been established.
The DITTO-HCV European funded project is for now the largest
study of frequent early viral kinetics during therapy with
peginterferon-alfa and ribavirin. The researchers aim to
optimize viral kinetics prediction criteria in order to enable
stopping or tailoring treatment as early as possible.
Primary objectives: 1) negative predictive value (NPV) as close
as possible to 100% (thus minimalizing stopped patients with
missed SVR), 2) high specificity (thus increasing the fraction
of patients that can be safely stopped). 3) a high positive
predictive value (PPV) using the same criteria.
134 chronically HCV infected naïve patients received
peginterferon-alfa-2a (40KD) (Pegasys ®) (180 μg qw) plus
ribavirin (Copegus ®) (1000-1200 mg qd) for 48 weeks. Of those,
67%, 28%, 4% and 1% had HCV genotype 1, 2-3, 4 or 5
respectively. Viral kinetics were measured according to
centralized serum HCV RNA quantifications on days 0, 1, 4, 7, 8,
15, 22 and 29 (Cobas Amplicor® HCV Monitor v2,
Roche). SVR was defined as undetectable serum HCV RNA (<50 IU/ml)
after 24 weeks of follow-up post treatment. The early viral
response prediction criteria (EVR) and thresholds tested here
(see Table 1 below) were prospectively defined.
Study
Results
The overall SVR rate was 64%. The EVR studied, together with
their NPV, PPV, specificity (SP), statistical significance and
number of HCV-RNA quantifications needed (NSMP), are given in
Table 1 below.
TABLE 1
|
EVR criteria definitions |
Week |
NSMP |
NPV |
SP |
PPV |
P |
N |
Week-12
(HCV RNA negative
and/or decline >2 log at week 12) |
12 |
2 |
100% |
21% |
68% |
0.001 |
128 |
2nd-slope
(2nd-slope at days 8-15-22-29
faster than 0.3 log/wk) |
4 |
3-5 |
<90% |
<40% |
<74% |
0.001 |
128 |
DITTO-2nd-slope
(combination of rapid slope between
days 8-29 and/or days 15-29) |
4 |
4 |
100% |
34% |
72% |
0.001 |
128 |
Week-1-decline
(Decline > 0.5 log at day 1, 4 or 7) |
1 |
2 |
<71% |
<37% |
<72% |
0.001 |
127 |
Week-1-VL
(VL < 5.5 log at day 1, 4 or 7) |
1 |
2 |
<77% |
<30% |
<70% |
0.004 |
127 |
DITTO-1st-week
(VL < 5.5 log on day 4
and/or decline > 0.5 log at day 7) |
1 |
3 |
100% |
28% |
70% |
0.001 |
127 |
The EVR-w12 criteria has good NPV (100%) but its specificity is
low (21%), thus relatively few non-responders can be stopped.
None of the simple 2nd-slope or Week-1 criteria shows NPV higher
than 90%, thus not adequate for a stopping rule.
A new composite criteria (DITTO-2nd-slp) gives NPV=100% and
specificity=34% already after 4 weeks of treatment. Furthermore,
another new composite criteria (DITTO-1st-week) also gives NPV=100%
with specificity=28% already after 1 week.
Although
composite, these new criteria are simple to calculate and
necessitate only 1 or 2 more viral quantifications compared to
the current Week-12 criteria. Thus allowing to lower the mean
cost by 2410 USD per patient. Note that SVR (56% for gen 1 and
87% for gen 2-3) is predicted independently of genotype.
Moreover, by selecting more strict thresholds for the
DITTO-1st-week (e.g. 4.5 log at day 4 and 2 log decline at day
7) and DITTO-2nd-slope (e.g, 0.6 log/week) criteria one can
obtain higher PPV up to 90%.
Conclusions:
Sustained viral response to treatment with peginterferon-alfa-2a
(40KD) and ribavirin can be predicted, independent of genotype,
as early as 1 or 4 weeks of treatment by new composite, but
still simple and practical, criteria of viral kinetics. Similar
NPV and PPV and better specificity was obtained here by the
DITTO-1st-week or DITTO-2nd-slope prediction criteria, giving
rise to significantly lower cost/effect as compared to the
current stopping rule at 12 weeks. These results warrant future
prospective testing in larger trials, since they can give rise
to considerable saving in cost and quality of life related to
over-treatment or alternatively allow early tailoring of
treatment.
Discussion
Can the new
predictive criteria move the current 12- week stopping rule to
under a month?
The DITTO-HCV
study retrospectively identified two new criteria to classify
rapid viral responders and predict the likely treatment outcome.
For the DITTO-1st week criterion viral levels are
measured at baseline and two times in the first week of
treatment; while the DITTO-2nd slope criterion uses
three measurements of viral levels between the second and fourth
week of treatment.
“Both of these
new criteria predicted who was and who was not likely to respond
to treatment more accurately than the existing 12-week stopping
rule. We had obtained 100 per cent negative predictive value (NPV)
and 90 per cent positive predictive value (PPV) with these
criteria” said
Professor
Avidan
Neumann, from the Bar-Ilan University, Israel, and the DITTO-HCV
study coordinator who presented the study results at an oral
session at AASLD.
Using these
criteria for stopping treatment in patients predicted early on
not to respond will make treatment more cost-effective, even
considering the added cost of the extra measurements of viral
load.
“This is
good news for patients and physicians. Using these new
criteria, we will be able to very early, identify more of those
patients who will ultimately not achieve an SVR so we can advise
them to stop taking their medication, thus improving their
quality of life,” said
Professor
Neumann.
“We now know
that tailoring treatment according to viral kinetics cannot
improve SVR rates with the treatment choices we have at the
moment. However, by measuring viral levels earlier in
treatment, a test physicians are already familiar with, we can
likely move the stopping rule currently defined at week 12 down
to week 4 or even week 1 and avoid having patients who will not
achieve an SVR being treated unnecessarily. These novel
prediction algorithms will hopefully be confirmed soon by other
clinical trials and their feasibility in clinical practice will
be assessed, thus allowing us to optimize the treatment of
hepatitis C patients," concluded Prof. Neumann.
10/27/03
Reference
AU Neumann and others. EARLY VIRAL KINETICS PREDICTION OF
SUSTAINED VIROLOGICAL RESPONSE AFTER 1 OR 4 WEEKS OF
PEG-INTERFERON-ALFA-2A AND RIBAVIRIN THERAPY
A Comparison of Standard Treatment
Versus Dynamically Individualized Treatment in Patients with
Chronic Hepatitis C
Combination therapy with peginterferon alfa and ribavirin for 48
weeks achieves sustained virologic response rates (SVR) of
54-61% in patients with chronic hepatitis C. However, the SVR
rates are highly variable according to baseline (HCV genotype)
and on-treatment parameters (initial viral decline). Thus, it
must be anticipated that current standard therapy
recommendations lead to under-treatment in some and
over-treatment in other individual patients.
Comparison between a dynamically individualized treatment
schedule according to the early virologic response versus the
standard of care combination therapy with peginterferon alfa-2a
(40KD) (Pegasys) (PEG-IFN) (180 μg qw) plus ribavirin (Copegus)
(RBV) (1000-1200 mg qd) for 48 weeks.
The primary aim of the study was to increase SVR, while
optimizing the available drugs, treatment duration, quality of
life and the socio-economical burden of therapy. The secondary
aim of the study was to enable a comprehensive analysis of
viral/host/immune correlates of response to treatment (ongoing).
All patients (n=273) were initially treated with PEG-IFN/RBV for
6 weeks and initial viral kinetics were defined according to
centralized serum HCV RNA quantifications (Cobas Amplicor HCV
Monitor v2, Roche Molecular Systems) on baseline and days 0, 1,
4, 7, 8, 15, 22 and 29.
After classification into viral response categories at 6 weeks,
patients were randomized (n=270) to individualized therapy (arms
A1, A2, B1, B2, C, D) or continuation of standard therapy (STD
arm). Treatment tailoring included: in rapid viral responders (RVR)
- discontinuation of RBV (A1) or shortening of treatment
duration to 24 weeks (A2); in slow partial responders (SPR) -
addition of histamine (B1) or prolongation of treatment to 72
weeks (B2); in flat partial responders (FPR) - addition of
histamine (C); in null responders (NUR) - retreatment with
high-dose of PEG-IFN (360 μg qw) plus RBV (D). SVR was defined
as undetectable serum HCV RNA (< 50 IU/ml) at the end of 24
weeks of untreated follow-up.
Study Results
Demographic and baseline virologic parameters were similar in
the standard and the individualized treatment groups. According
to the initial viral decline patients were categorized as RVR
(51% for genotype 1 and 94% for genotype 2-3), SPR (35% and 5%
accordingly), FPR (5% and 0% accordingly), NUR (10% and 1%
accordingly) or unclassified (1%). The overall SVR rates for
genotype 1 patients were 49% for the individualized and 56% for
the standard treatment arm (NS), and for genotype 2-3 patients
90% and 87% respectively (NS). SVR rates (by ITT analysis)
according to HCV genotype and within each initial viral response
category and arm are given in Table 1 below.
Table 1
| |
Rapid responders
(RVR) |
Slow responders
(SPR) |
Flat responders
(FPR) |
Null responders
(NUR) |
|
Genotype |
A1 |
A2 |
STD |
B1 |
B2 |
STD |
C |
STD |
D |
STD |
HCV-1
|
79% |
65% |
79% |
0% |
46% |
40% |
20% |
0% |
10% |
10% |
HCV-2,3
|
89% |
95% |
89% |
-- |
-- |
-- |
-- |
-- |
-- |
-- |
Conclusions
The overall sustained virologic response rates of 53% in
genotype 1 and 88% in genotype 2-3 patients with chronic
hepatitis C treated with Pegasys (peginterferon alfa-2a/40KD) in
combination with ribavirin support previously presented data.
Individualized treatment according to initial viral kinetics
appears to be clinically feasible, but did not improve the
sustained virologic response rate with the drugs and dosages
usable at the time of this study.
Nevertheless, the possibility that in rapid viral responders
discontinuation of ribavirin does not decrease the sustained
virologic response rate warrants future prospective trials.
Discussion
Rapid Viral
Responders Have Most Promising Results
Rapid viral
responders were prospectively defined as patients whose HCV RNA
declined by at least 99 per cent during the first month of
treatment. The study found that in this sub-group, even the most
difficult-to-treat genotype 1 patients could achieve 83% SVR.
A relatively
high SVR rate (71%) was obtained even for the rapid responding
patients treated with ribavirin for only the first 6 weeks
instead of the standard regimen of ribavirin during the whole
peginterferon treatment of 48 weeks. These SVR rates are similar
to that achieved by genotype 2/3 patients (88%), who
traditionally have been easier to treat.
“It is
therefore critical for these rapid responding patients to be
identified” said Professor
Zeuzem.
Supported by the European Community (QLK2-2000-00836), Hoffmann
La-Roche and Maxim Pharmaceuticals.
10/24/03
References
S Zeuzem and
others (for the The DITTO-HCV study--Dynamically Individualized
Treatment of Hepatitis C Infection and
Correlates of Viral/Host Dynamics study).
INTERNATIONAL, MULTICENTER, RANDOMIZED, CONTROLLED STUDY
COMPARING STANDARD VERSUS DYNAMICALLY INDIVIDUALIZED TREATMENT
IN PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC HEPATITIS C (DITTO-HCV PROJECT).
Abstract 317 (poster). 54th AASLD.
October 24-28, 2003. Boston, MA.
Ribavirin Dosage Significantly Affects
Virological Response Rates in HCV Patients Treated with
Interferon/Ribavirin
The
influence of absolute dose and dose in mg per kg body weight of
ribavirin on sustained virologic response (SVR) in
interferon-based combination treatment of chronic hepatitis C as
well as the influence of dose reduction is still controversial.
In this
study, investigators address this problem by reanalyzing data of
343 previously untreated patients with chronic hepatitis C from
a multicenter trial who were treated with Pegasys (interferon
alfa-2a) plus ribavirin and amantadine or interferon alfa-2a
plus ribavirin (Berg et al, Hepatology 2003, 37,
1359-1367) and completed therapy.
The
researchers used a multivariate approach to account for
correlations of the dose of ribavirin with body weight and body
mass index (BMI) and known predictor variables from this data
set which are low baseline HCV RNA, high platelet counts, high
pretreatment ALT, and low γ glutamyl transpeptidase (GGT) as
well as HCV genotype non-1.
Because per
protocol, dosage of ribavirin was weight-adjusted (1000 mg for
body weight below 75 kg and 1200 mg for body weight 75 kg or
more) and body weight was positively correlated with GGT and
negatively correlated with platelet counts, respectively, the
investigators used a stratification with respect to genotype (GT
1 vs. non-1), GGT, and platelet counts in the analysis of
ribavirin dose.
When
comparing body weight, BMI, the absolute intention to treat
(ITT) ribavirin dose as well as the ITT dose of ribavirin
measured in mg per kg body weight and the respective ribavirin
doses at the end of treatment (EOT), a significant association
with SVR was found for the EOT ribavirin dosage (mg per kg body
weight) and BMI (p=1.8% and p=3.0%, respectively).
For
predicting SVR, a weight-based ribavirin dosage threshold of
13.75 mg/kg was calculated using receiver operating
characteristics (ROC) curves. The SVR rate was 66% (112/169) in
patients with a ribarivin dose of more than 13.75 mg/kg as
compared with 46% (79/172) in patients receiving equal or less
than 13.75 mg/kg ribavirin at EOT.
In
conclusion, the analysis of ribavirin dosage motivates new
considerations of weight-adjustments of the ribavirin dosage to
further increase SVR in HCV-infected patients treated with
combination therapy.
10/27/03
Reference
E Herrmann and others. IMPORTANCE OF RIBAVIRIN DOSAGE ON
VIROLOGICAL RESPONSE RATES IN PATIENTS CHRONICALLY INFECTED WITH
HEPATITIS C VIRUS AND TREATED WITH INTERFERON-BASED COMBINATION
THERAPY. Abstract 296 (poster).
54th
AASLD. October 24-28, 2003. Boston, MA.
Preliminary Data Do Not Support Hypothesis
That Higher SVR Rates in Genotype 1 HCV Patients Result from
Extending Treatment from 48 to 72 Weeks
Treatment of
patients infected with hepatitis C virus (HCV) genotype 1 (G1)
remains a challenge necessitating innovative strategies to
improve treatment outcome. Viral kinetic studies have shown that
turnover of hepatocytes infected with HCV G1 is slower than in
other genotypes. This implies that more aggressive antiviral
treatments are required in patients infected with HCV G1.
Extending the treatment duration beyond 48 weeks is one strategy
that may improve response rates in these difficult-to-treat
patients.
The purpose of the current study was to compare the efficacy and
safety of 48 weeks versus 72 weeks of treatment with
peginterferon alfa-2a (40KD) (PEGASYS) in combination with
ribavirin (COPEGUS) in treatment-naïve patients infected with
HCV G1.
This multicenter, national, randomized, open-label parallel
group study was conducted in accordance with local and
international GCP guidelines. Treatment-naïve patients infected
with HCV G1, aged ≥18 years with CHC infection, HCV RNA levels
>1000 copies/mL, elevated ALT levels, liver biopsy findings
consistent with a diagnosis of CHC, and compensated liver
disease (Child-Pugh grade A) were eligible for the study.
After screening and signing of informed consent forms, patients
were randomized to treatment with peginterferon alfa-2a (40KD) (PEGASY)
180 μg once weekly plus ribavirin (COPEGUS) 800 mg/day (400 mg
BID) for either 48 weeks or 72 weeks. Patients were followed for
an additional 24 weeks after the end of treatment. Virological
response was defined as undetectable HCV RNA (<50 IU/mL by COBAS
AMPLICOR HCV Test, v2.0, Roche Diagnostics) at the end of
follow-up.
To date
459 patients have been enrolled in the trial and 305 have
completed follow-up. The two treatment groups were comparable
with regard to baseline characteristics. The results of the
study, presented as intent-to-treat, missing data = failure
(ITT; M=F), and on-treatment (OT) analysis (only patients with
data included) are captured in the Table 1 below.
No major differences were observed in the frequency or intensity
of SAEs and AEs.
Conclusions
The combination of peginterferon alfa-2a (40KD) (PEGASYS) and
ribavirin (COPEGUS) was safe and effective in patients with HCV
genotype 1. Despite the use of a dose of ribavirin (800 mg/day)
that is lower than the recommended dose for patients infected
with G1 (1000/1200 mg/day), approximately half of the patients
in the study achieved an SVR.
Because the study could not be blinded, a bias might have
influenced the outcome of the study as suggested by the unequal
discontinuation rate. These preliminary data do not support the
hypothesis that higher SVR rates can be achieved in patients
with HCV G1 by extending treatment duration.
| |
48 weeks
of treatment |
72 weeks
of treatment |
Patients with HCV RNA<50 IU/ml
(%)*
|
| |
ITT; M=F
(n = 221) |
OT
(n = 221) |
ITT; M=F
(n = 215) |
OT
(n = 215) |
|
Treatment wk 12 |
119/221 (54) |
119/207 (58) |
109/215 (51) |
109/197 (55) |
|
Treatment wk 24 |
149/221 (67) |
149/203 (73) |
137/215 (64) |
137/202 (68) |
|
Treatment wk 48 |
141/221 (64) |
142/169 (84) |
131/215 (61) |
131/156 (84) |
|
Treatment wk 72 |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
115/215 (54) |
115/140 (82) |
|
Follow-up wk 12 |
113/221 (51) |
113/192 (59) |
97/215 (42) |
97/167 (58) |
|
Follow-up wk 24 |
107/221 (48) |
107/181 (59) |
90/215 (42) |
90/157 (57) |
|
Discontinuation for any reason** |
|
Overall (%) |
58/231 (25.1) |
93/225 (41.3) |
|
Before wk 48 (%) |
56/231 (24.2) |
53/225 (23.6) |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
*ITT population, defined as all patients who took at least
one dose of study medication and had at least one HCV RNA
evaluation post-baseline.
**Safety population, defined as all patients who took at least
one dose of the study medication.
10/27/03
Reference
T Berg
and others (German Pegasys + Copegus Genotype 1 HCV Study
Group).
COMPARISON OF 48 OR 72 WEEKS OF TREATMENT WITH PEGINTERFERON
ALFA-2A (40KD) (PEGASYS®) PLUS RIBAVIRIN (COPEGUS®)
IN TREATMENT-NAÏVE PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC HEPATITIS C INFECTED
WITH HCV GENOTYPE 1. Abstract 328 (poster). 54th
AASLD. October 24-28, 2003. Boston, MA.
Patients with Increased Symptoms of
Depression During Interferon/Ribavirin Therapy Are Less Likely
to Clear HCV
Interferon (IFN)-alfa
plus ribavirin is an effective treatment for chronic hepatitis C
virus (HCV) infection, but is associated with a high rate of
depression. Depressive symptoms have been linked to a worse
outcome in a number of medical disorders.
To determine
whether increased depressive symptoms during IFN alfa/ribavirin
therapy were associated with reduced clearance of HCV, a
prospective cohort design was used to evaluate HCV-infected
patients at baseline and after 4, 8, 12 and 24 weeks of
pegylated IFN-alfa-2b/ribavirin therapy.
The sample was
derived from patients enrolled in a larger multi-center,
randomized clinical trial of PEG-Intron (pegylated IFN-alfa-2b)
plus fixed-dose versus weight-based ribavirin. 102 HCV-infected
subjects who volunteered to participate and completed 24 weeks
of IFN alfa/ribavirin treatment followed by viral load testing
were included.
Severity of
depressive symptoms was measured by the Zung Self-Rating
Depression Scale (SDS). Viral clearance was defined as
polymerase chain reaction (PCR) negative (less than 29 HCV IU/ml)
at 24 weeks.
Study Results
Increased
depressive symptoms during IFN-alfa/ribavirin therapy were
associated with reduced viral clearance (P=0.006). Only 34% of
subjects with a 20-point or greater increase in SDS Index (N=29)
were HCV PCR negative at 24 weeks, compared to 63% of patients
without a 20-point increase (N=73). These results remained
significant after adjusting for ribavirin dose assignment, viral
genotype, age, antidepressant usage, IFN-alfa/ribavirin dosage
reduction and knowledge of viral load status during treatment.
Cumulative
depressive symptoms over the 24 weeks of IFN-alfa/ribavirin
therapy also predicted failure to clear virus (P=0.026).
Conclusions
HCV patients
who experience significant increases in symptoms of depression
during IFN-alfa/ribavirin therapy are less likely to clear
virus, highlighting the potential importance of identifying and
treating depressive symptoms in this patient population.
10/27/03
References
CL Raison and
others. DEPRESSIVE SYMPTOMS DURING IFN-ALPHA/RIBAVIRIN THERAPY
ARE ASSOCIATED WITH REDUCED VIRAL CLEARANCE IN PATIENTS WITH
HEPATITIS C. Abstract 344 (poster). Program and Abstracts of the
54th AASLD. October 24-28, 2003. Boston, MA.
Age and Adherence Are Significant Predictors
of HCV Treatment Success
In clinical
trials, the overall sustained virological response (SVR) rates
to Pegasys (peginterferon alfa-2a) and Copegus (ribavirin)
combination therapy for chronic hepatitis C virus (HCV)
infection ranged from 56 to 61%.
The
probability of achieving an SVR varies significantly depending
upon the patient’s HCV genotype, viral load, histological status
and other factors. In patients infected with HCV genotype (GT)
1, only pretreatment viral load had a greater influence than age
on the probability of achieving an SVR.
In a study
presented at the 54th AASLD Conference, investigators
evaluated the influence of age and adherence on the probability
of achieving an SVR with Pegasys plus Copegus therapy in
patient’s infected with HCV GT 1.
The study used
data drawn from 2 international, randomized trials, in which 736
patients with chronic HCV GT 1 infection received Pegasys plus
Copegus. For the purpose of the analysis, an adherent patient
was defined as one who received the assigned dosages of Pegasys/Copegus
for ≥80% of the planned duration of treatment.
Of the 736
patients, 336 (45.6%) achieved an SVR and 597 (81.1%) were
considered adherent. When the model used in the analysis was
programmed for a non-cirrhotic, Caucasian patient with a
baseline ALT quotient of 3, HCV RNA level of 3.269 x 106
copies/ml and a BMI of 25, the probability of a
20-year-old patient achieving an SVR was significantly higher
than the probability for a 60-year-old doing so (74.4% vs.
44.2%, respectively).
When the model
parameters include, in addition to those mentioned above, an
assumption that the patient would be adherent, the probability
of achieving an SVR increased to 85.4% and 52.9%, respectively.
Based on these
data, the authors conclude, “In conclusion, patient age has a
profound influence on the probability of achieving an SVR with
peginterferon alfa-2a (40KD) and ribavirin therapy.
”Clinicians and their patients should consider the influence of
patient age on the timing of the decision to start treatment.
With our model, it is possible to predict the probability of
achieving an SVR in an individual patient, and to demonstrate
the impact of adherence on treatment outcome. This tool will be
useful in motivating patients to adhere to treatment.”
10/29/03
Reference
TREATMENT OF CHRONIC HEPATITIS C WITH PEGINTERFERON
ALFA-2A (40KD) (PEGASYS®) AND RIBAVIRIN (COPEGUS®):
PATIENT AGE HAS A MARKED INFLUENCE ON THE INDIVIDUAL ESTIMATED
PROBABILITY OF ACHIEVING A SUSTAINED VIROLOGICAL RESPONSE.
Program and Abstracts of the 54th Annual Meeting of
the American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases.
October 24-28, 2003. Boston, MA.
Page Reviewed on Oct 27 03
RANTES Haplotypes Predictive of Sustained
Virological Response to HCV Treatment
The chemokine
RANTES (regulated upon activation, normally T cell expressed and
secreted/CCL5) is a potent chemo-attractant for Th1 cells, and
different RANTES gene variants affect HIV progression.
Recently the
most frequent functional gene variants of RANTES (-403G/A
and Intron1.1T/C) were shown to be in linkage disequilibrium in
a study presented at the 54th AASLD, the influence of
three common RANTES haplotypes (R1: -403G/Int1.1T, R2:
-403A/Int1.1T, R3: -403A/Int1.1C) on clinical, biochemical, and
histological parameters of patients with chronic hepatitis C
virus (HCV) infection was investigated.
In the study,
RANTES variants -403G/A and Int1.1T/C were genotyped by
RFLP-PCR analysis in 297 Caucasian patients with chronic
hepatitis C and 152 control patients without viral infection. Of
all patients with HCV infection, 268 underwent antiviral
combination therapy with standard interferon-alpha and ribavirin
and had at least one liver biopsy prior to treatment.
The allele
frequencies of the -403G/A and Int1.1C/T polymorphisms did not
differ between patients with HCV infection and controls. The
combined analysis of both polymorphisms revealed three common
haplotypes in chronic hepatitis C patients (R1 60.1%, R2 15.3%,
R3 24.6%).
The RANTES
haplotype R3 was detected significantly less frequently in
patients with sustained virological response (SVR) to antiviral
therapy (17.3%) compared to non-responders, whereas the other
haplotypes were equally distributed between responders and
non-responders.
Of note, the
difference in RANTES haplotype distribution regarding
outcome of antiviral therapy was also apparent in patients
infected with HCV genotypes 1 and 4 (n = 209, SVR R3 13.2% vs.
non-responders R3 30.0%; OR 2.7, P = 0.02).
Furthermore,
in logistic regression analysis RANTES haplotype was
associated with treatment outcome independently from HCV
genotype and stage of fibrosis/cirrhosis.
Based upon
these data, the authors conclude,
(1)
We detected a possible influence of interacting RANTES
gene variants on outcome of antiviral therapy with
interferon-alpha and ribavirin, which might have been missed in
earlier studies investigating the promoter polymorphism -403G/A
only.
(2)
Because the RANTES R3 haplotype has been
demonstrated to result in down-regulation of RANTES
transcriptional activity, these findings might serve to better
define the host's polygenic immune response that predisposes to
a positive or negative outcome of antiviral therapy in chronic
hepatitis C.”
*
Additional Sustained Virologic Response Stories from the 54th
AASLD
10/31/03
Reference
H Wasmuth and others. INTERACTING RANTES/CCL5 GENE
VARIANTS MODIFY THE RESPONSE TO COMBINATION THERAPY WITH
INTERFERON-ALPHA AND RIBAVIRIN IN PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC
HEPATITIS C. Abstract 188 (oral). 54th Annual Meeting
of the American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases.
October 24-28, 2003. Boston, MA.
Results of Long-term Follow Up of Sustained
Responders to Interferon Therapy in Chronic HCV Patients: A
Meta-analysis
Reference
BJ Veldt
and others (for the Eurohep study group). LONG TERM FOLLOW UP OF
SUSTAINED RESPONDERS TO INTERFERON ALPHA IN CHRONIC HEPATITIS C:
A META-ANALYSIS ASSESSING TRUE CLINICAL ENDPOINTS. Abstract 971
(poster).
54th Annual Meeting of the
American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases. October
24-28, 2003. Boston, MA.
A Dynamic Model to Predict Sustained
Virological Response to Combination Treatment with Pegasys and
Copegus in Patients with Chronic HCV
Overall, 56%
of patients achieved
sustained virological responses (SVR) after 48 weeks of
treatment with the combination of peginterferon alfa-2a (40KD)
(PEGASYS®) 180 μg/week and ribavirin (COPEGUS®)
1000 or 1200 mg/day in a large international, randomized, phase
3 trial. (Fried et al. N Engl J Med. 2002;347:975-982).
In this
study, 97% of patients without an early virological response (EVR),
defined as either a ≥2-log10 drop in viral load or
complete disappearance of HCV RNA in serum by 12 weeks of
therapy, failed to achieve an SVR. This information is useful
because it allows for the early termination of treatment in
those unlikely to respond to a full course of treatment.
The purpose of the current study was to refine the
ability to predict the likelihood of achieving a sustained
virological response after treatment with peginterferon alfa-2a
(40KD) and ribavirin, based on virological response data
obtained at week 4 and week 12 of therapy.
The dynamic model is based on data from patients treated with
peginterferon alfa-2a (40KD) 180 μg/week and ribavirin 1000 or
1200 mg/day for 48 weeks in a large, international, randomized
trial (Fried et al. N Engl J Med. 2002;347:975-982).
For the purpose of this analysis, an early virological response
(EVR) was defined as undetectable HCV RNA by qualitative
polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay (<50 IU/mL; COBAS AMPLICOR®
HCV Test, v2.0; Roche Diagnostics) or a decrease of ≥2 log10
in HCV RNA levels as determined by quantitative PCR (COBAS
AMPLICOR HCV MONITOR® Test, v2.0; Roche Diagnostics)
after 12 weeks of treatment.
For this analysis SVR was defined as a single undetectable HCV
RNA level by qualitative PCR on or after week 60. Treatment was
to be stopped in patients with detectable HCV RNA after 24
weeks.
Study Results
A total of 453 patients were randomized to treatment with
peginterferon alfa-2a (40KD) and ribavirin and received study
medication. The disposition of patients who were HCV RNA
negative after 24 weeks of treatment is shown in the Table below
and grouped according to their HCV RNA status at week 4, 12 and
24.
Patients with missing data at any of these time points were not
included in the analysis. Patients with ≥2-log10 drop
in HCV RNA levels at a given time point, and who were negative
at the previous and following time point, were grouped with
patients assessed as HCV RNA negative at that time point (n =
8).
The probability of achieving an SVR increased in inverse
proportion to the time taken to achieve undetectable HCV RNA
levels. Thus, the highest SVR rate (89%) and, correspondingly,
the lowest relapse rate during follow-up (8%), was obtained in
patients who were consistently HCV RNA negative at weeks 4, 12
and 24.
Conclusions
-
The outcome
of combination therapy with peginterferon alfa-2a (40KD)
(PEGASYS®) and ribavirin (COPEGUS®) is
highly dependent on the rapidity of the virological response;
-
Patients who
become HCV RNA negative after 4 weeks have the best chance for
achieving an SVR;
-
It may be
hypothesized that to decrease the frequency of relapse in the
remaining patients, treatment longer than 48 weeks may be
required. This approach should be tested in a prospective
trial.
HCV-RNA
Status
|
|
EOT Resp*
n |
SVR
N (%) |
Relapse during follow-up n (%) |
|
Week 4 |
Week 12 |
Week 24 |
N |
|
Negative |
Negative |
Negative |
112 |
96 |
100 (89%) |
7 (7%) |
|
≥2-log drop |
Negative |
Negative |
132 |
116 |
99 (75%) |
24 (21%) |
|
<2-log drop |
Negative |
Negative |
24 |
21 |
18 (75%) |
6 (29%) |
|
≥2-log drop |
≥2-log drop |
Negative |
26 |
21 |
13 (50%) |
9 (43%) |
|
<2-log drop |
≥2-log drop |
Negative |
33 |
30 |
15 (45%) |
15 (50%) |
* End of
treatment response (EOT) = HCV RNA negative at week 48.
11/19/03
Reference
P Ferenci and others. A DYNAMIC MODEL TO PREDICT SUSTAINED
VIROLOGICAL RESPONSE TO COMBINATION PEGINTERFERON ALFA-2A (40KD)
(PEGASYS®) AND RIBAVIRIN (COPEGUS®)
THERAPY IN PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC HEPATITIS C. Abstract 995
(poster).
Hepatology
38:4 (Suppl). October 2003. (54th
Annual Meeting of the American Association for the Study of
Liver Diseases. October 24-28, 2003. Boston, MA.)
|